Fantasy Basketball Weekend Must-Starts: Ajay Mitchell set to step up with starters out

  • Noah Rubin
  • January 9, 2026
Fantasy managers searching for weekend upside plays have a new name to circle: Ajay Mitchell. With multiple starters expected to sit, the rookie guard is walking into the kind of short-term opportunity that can swing head‑to‑head matchups and tighten the margins in roto leagues.

Mitchell’s appeal starts with role. Any time a rotation compresses, fantasy value follows the minutes, and Mitchell is positioned to absorb a significant share of the vacated backcourt workload. That likely means more time on the ball, increased usage in second units, and a longer leash to play through mistakes. For fantasy purposes, that combination is often more important than raw talent or long-term outlook.

His profile fits what managers should target in a weekend streamer. Mitchell is a capable on‑ball creator who can generate drives, kick‑outs, and secondary playmaking opportunities. That tends to translate into points, assists, and free throw attempts, with a realistic chance at a handful of threes if his jumper is falling. Even if the scoring isn’t fully there, the volume alone should put him in position to deliver usable counting stats across multiple categories.

There is also situational context working in his favor. Opponents are likely to game‑plan for the established options who remain, not a freshly elevated guard still earning league-wide recognition. That can create softer defensive matchups, especially when he’s staggered against second units, and it often leads to extra possessions in transition and semi‑transition where fantasy lines are built.

Of course, there is volatility. Young guards can be turnover-prone and streaky as shooters, and a quick hook is always possible if he struggles defensively. But in fantasy, especially over a short weekend slate, managers are often better off chasing ceiling rather than settling for low-upside veterans.

In that context, Mitchell belongs on the “must‑start” list. If he’s available, he should be added and streamed. If he’s already on your bench, this is the moment to get him into active lineups and see whether expanded opportunity can translate into a breakout fantasy weekend.